So it verse is quite much like the very first verse of the songster text

Lyle’s rewritten six verse text message is approximately synchronous with the songster text message after deletion of your own 4th verse of latter. Lyle’s rewritten version, however, has the regiment likely to Kilkenny, instead of Killarney. Lyle’s track was “The Bonnie Blue Ignore-Me-Maybe not,” which had been given for the Roentgen. An excellent. Smith’s The latest Irish Minstrel , letter.d. [1825, the first, allegedly stored, edition]. New title of track could there be considering once the “The brand new Housemaid off Derby.” If you are Lyle’s text “Rather Peg from Derby” try meaningless due to the fact a timeless tune, we are able to ensure “Fairly Peggy off Derby” is actually sung in Scotland in the first one-fourth of your nineteenth century that have a book nearly the same as you to definitely from the songster asia brides. [Incongrously, Lyle’s text rather than a chapbook otherwise broadside backup seems Roy Palmer’s present Everyman’s Publication away from Ballads. ]

Cahusac from inside the 1788, and you may one piece tune which have songs is actually a couple Western selections, “Peggy of Darby”, and this kicks off “There can be a good gay Master when you look at the Darby Urban area”

Possibly somewhat prior to “Pretty Peggy from Derby, O” try rewritten since the “The fresh new Bonnie Lass o’ Fyvie” given that confirmed by the a duplicate in Peter Buchan’s MSS regarding Uk Collection, which can be believed to date on 1828.

The initial range and a half, almost the same as men and women significantly more than, are also when you look at the an effective medley in Vol. I, p. cuatro, 1825. Discover songs into track “Very Peggy out of Derby, O” towards the p. 107 and you can 276 out-of Vol. III, 1828, and first line out of “Peggy out-of Darby” is during a good medley into the p. 284.

Lyle in addition to authored a special song on the tune, offered from the work cited, and you can printed prior to with musical

T. Crofton Crocker in the Prominent Tunes regarding Ireland , London, 1839, p. 124 (p. 121 away from 1886 reprint), claims, “The new fairly Maid off Derby, O!” is proven to be the production of a keen Irishman, however, getting will bring zero specifics almost any, not really bringing up in which a duplicate of the text or tune would-be located. It seems that Crocker asked his customers to get familiar into the track and song. Evidence quoted a lot more than seems to us to getting slightly definitive when deciding to take “Quite Peggy out-of Derby” to get an Irish song and you will song. Devoid of which evidence, yet not, there were counterclaims. Wm. Chappell during the Sound of one’s Olden Big date , II, p. 771, detailed Crocker’s allege, but designed that the song wasn’t Irish, but not, the guy provided no head research. Chappell’s statement that Bunting rejected it’s in place of base. Bunting don’t speak about the fresh new tune, that’s definitely not the same as claiming the guy rejected they. Donnal O’Sullivan, concurs having Chappell in his review of Irish Folk music inside the the latest fifth ed. regarding Grove’s Dictionary , but alludes to no research specialist otherwise scam, therefore we do not know exactly what proof he’d seen, or no.

Lastly, a few points We have not yet , seen. There can be a duplicate of tune in a good flute teacher compiled by T. BUCEM listing zero content of this regarding Uk Isles.

Unrelated: “Drops of Brandy” are a significantly elderly not related song off comparable name, often referred to as “Dribbles out of Brandy.” The latter title Thomson’s tune toward listen their Edinburgh ballad opera ‘The Troubled Gallant’, 1738. A few years after this tune was duplicated on NLS MS 6299. This new song you will violation for the amazing one to towards the track when we failed to remember that the brand new track try before. “The fresh new Dandy, O,” Thomas Moore’s tune getting their track “Young May Moon” for the 5th quantity of Irish Melodies , letter.d. try an alternate tune in six/8 time which have similar label, obviously provided by Moore in the chorus of a song within the Robin Hood in which the track checked in the place of identity.